Leafs 2022-2023

Creative, but I don't think it gets the Leafs anywhere.
I don't think Anaheim does that, but if they did, it would obvious that Gibson isn't the goalie he used to be.

The Philly deal seems like an L for both teams tbh

Not even close for John Gibson, And reportedly all Canadian teams are on his no trade list. Another American the supposedly doesn't want to play in Canada.

I don’t see a world where we get what we would want/a team pay it for Gibson currently

Flyers decline, I like Konecny+ for Nylander but we can't give up our 2023 1st

If Gibson is still the elite goaltender who started the season 15-10-8 with a GAA of 2.46 and a save percentage of 0.924, which made him only one of 9 goalies with a GAA under 2.5 who saved over 92% of his shots against, then this is too little for him.

If Gibson is the guy who has gone 2-11-1 in 2022 and seen his GAA balloon to 3.09 while his save % dropped to 0.904, then this is probably the right value.