SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

jbigs11

jbigs11
Membre depuis
8 févr. 2018
Équipe favorite
Rangers de New York
Deuxième équipe favorite
Oilers d'Edmonton
Messages dans les forums
105
Messages par jour
0.0
Forum: Armchair-GM9 févr. 2020 à 15 h 47
Sujet: NYR TDL Kreider to STL Geo to SJS Fast to EDM
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>bsilk18</b></div><div>Fair, to me it seemed that the rangers had more forward prospects (not to mention zboril is a much better prospect than Toropchenko)... as far as Kuhlman vs Blias, i guess Blias is a little better, but its not THAT drastic of a difference. Its like saying "id take Hughes 9 out of 10 times of Kakko"... it was actually much closer at the draft than people thought.</div></div>

100%, Blais vs Kuhlman isn't a huge difference but he's younger, a little more experienced and he plays a style that I personally think David Quinn would really love.

Zboril is definitely better than Toropchenko, but I like how he's a pretty versatile forward. Can play left or right wing and the Rangers are gonna be especially weak on the left side. He's had some great stints in the AHL, but so has Zboril. Unfortunately, the left side is somewhat crowded from a prospect perspective on the Rangers. To be honest, I think either deal is enough to get it done, the difference in the two is fairly minimal but enough so that I still prefer STL.
Forum: Armchair-GM25 janv. 2020 à 2 h 5
Sujet: Georgiev To DET
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Sagecoll</b></div><div>Top 6 ceiling...</div></div>

I had this written out elsewhere so I didn't just type this but these are some comparable goalie trades, similar to Georgiev. Potential future starter, &lt;30 years old. Age then stats at trade time are shown in parentheses. For reference, here are Georgiev’s comparables (23 / 23 GP, .910 SV%, 3.11 GAA). What makes Georgiev different that he's getting a top-six ceiling player?

6/22/18 Brooks Orpik, Philipp Grubauer (26 / 35 GP, .923 SV%, 2.35 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2018 2nd Round Pick
2/21/18 Darcy Kuemper (27 / 19 GP, .932 SV%, 2.33 GAA) &lt;&gt; Tobias Reider, Scott Wedgewood
2/19/18 Petr Mrazek [$2 mil retained] (25 / 22 GP, .910 SV%, 2.89 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2018 3rd Round Pick*, 2019 3rd Round Pick*
6/23/17 Derek Stepan, Antti Raanta (28 / 30 GP, .922 SV%, 2.26 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2017 1st Round Pick, Tony DeAngelo
4/28/17 Scott Darling (28 / 32 GP, .924 SV%, 2.38 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2017 3rd Round Pick
6/20/16 Frederik Andersen (26 / 43 GP, .919 SV%, 2.30 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2016 1st Round Pick, 2017 2nd Round Pick*
6/30/16 Martin Jones (23 / 15 GP, .906 SV%, 2.24 GAA) &lt;&gt; Sean Kuraly, 2016 1st Round Pick
6/27/15 Cam Talbot (27 / 36 GP, .926 SV%, 2.21 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2015 3rd Round Pick, 2015 2nd Round Pick, 2015 7th Round Pick
6/27/15 Eddie Lack (27 / 41 GP, .921 SV%, 2.45 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2015 3rd Round Pick, 2016 7th Round Pick
5/1/14 Jaroslav Halak (28 / 52 GP, .921 SV%, 2.25 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2014 4th Round Pick
3/4/14 Viktor Fasth (31 / 5 GP, .885 SV%, 2.95 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2015 3rd Round Pick, 2014 5th Round Pick
6/30/13 Cory Schneider (26 / 30 GP, .927 SV%, 2.11 SV% &lt;&gt; 2013 1st Round Pick
6/23/13 Jonathan Bernier (24 / 14 GP, .922 SV%, 1.87 GAA) &lt;&gt; Ben Scrivens, Matt Fratin, 2015 2nd Round Pick
4/3/13 Steve Mason (24 / 13 GP, .899 SV%, 2.95 GAA) &lt;&gt; Michael Leighton, 2015 3rd Round Pick
6/22/12 Sergei Bobrovsky (23 / 29 GP, .899 SV%, 3.02 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2013 4th Round Pick, 2012 2nd Round Pick, 2012 4th Round Pick
2/26/12 Ben Bishop (24 / 7 GP, .899 SV%, 2,77 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2013 2nd Round Pick
7/1/12 Semyon Varlamov (22 / 27 GP, .924 SV%, 2.23 GAA) &lt;&gt; 2012 1st Round Pick, 2012 2nd Round Pick
Forum: Armchair-GM25 janv. 2020 à 1 h 18
Sujet: Georgiev To DET
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Sagecoll</b></div><div>I don't think Detroit has the horses to get something done then. Unless they want to trade for something like Veleno straight up.

You can probably get a good haul from a team like Minnesota. 6th worst SV% in the league playing behind a Very Very good Defense. No real great goaltending prospects in the pool. Would be an almost certain playoff team with Georgiev.

I could see something structured around their 1st or a 2nd + Khovanov.</div></div>

I really doubt that DET becomes the eventual winner in the Georgiev sweepstakes but I thought this was an interesting trade for both sides and it works well. Khovanov is great but I'd bet MIN wants to keep him so they have some Russians in the room for Kaprizov. They're having enough trouble convincing him to come over as it is. Plus, that's the same problem as DET. The Rangers are looking for a player that they can insert into the lineup immediately. Khovanov does not fit that bill.

Jordan Greenway is a guy I could see the Rangers targeting in a deal with the Wild. Similar structured deal, high-ish pick with Greenway.
Forum: Armchair-GM25 janv. 2020 à 1 h 4
Forum: Armchair-GM25 janv. 2020 à 0 h 48
Sujet: Georgiev To DET
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Sagecoll</b></div><div>Yeah Rangers decline.

Hirose: 0.54 Even Strength pts/60 as a 23 year old Winger with Frans Nielsen and Brendan Perlini as his most common linemates
Lias Andersson: 0.47 Even Strength pts/60 as a 21 year old Center with Brendan Smith and Michael Haley as his most common linemates.

And this is the guy you want to headline the deal?

There are a few possible options from Detroit : Jonatan Berggren and Robert Mastrosimone.

Hirose just doesn't have the ceiling to be considered here. Georgiev's value is around a late 1st.</div></div>

I considered them but the Rangers have made it pretty clear that they're looking for a roster player in the deal. If it were one of those two, getting a 2nd or 3rd round pick becomes much less likely.
Forum: Armchair-GM25 janv. 2020 à 0 h 45
Sujet: Georgiev To DET
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>YoucancallmeHockeyman</b></div><div>Bruh, alongside the fact that your reasoning is pourous, as a team that is full of passers, adding one more sounds like the exact thing they need..right?

Please, do not sell me on the notion that this is a good idea. His .54 even strength points/60 can be an asset; but, his points are a result of 76% primary assists. So, on a team where Panarin, Buchnevich, Strome, Fast, Howden and all but one of the defensemen (Staal) generate their points on primary assists, you want to add one more passer, and utilize a great asset in Georgiev on such a little deal?

Yeah..no.</div></div>

I'm sorry I don't understand your reasoning one bit. It's insatiably nitpicky. What do you want for Georgiev? An established 30-goal scorer? This is his value, like it or not. Young roster player and decent pick.

Also, using primary assists as a negative is insane reasoning. I don't see how Howden is related, he has one 5v5 primary assist this year. Fast isn't in the top 5 amongst forwards in 5v5 primary assists. Your reasoning is flawed by a country mile. Let's not forget that Fast could be gone in the offseason/trade deadline, and Kreider (who's fourth in 5v5 primary assists) could be gone too. That's a lot of offense on the wing that needs to be filled. I don't see why Hirose can't be that guy.

He's got decent possession stats and his isolated offensive impact is strong for a guy with that experience. I think you're wildly overlooking his value for a rebuild and overvaluing Georgiev as a trade piece. Recent trades for goalies of his age/stats show that this is what the return should look like.
Forum: Armchair-GM27 févr. 2018 à 14 h 43
Sujet: Major signing jump starting the rebuild to be competitive in 2018-19
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Spanky227</b></div><div>Kovy is a right handed shot that can play RW if needed. Spooner is a natural center that was moved to the wing. Whichever of Necas or Andersson is more ready for the center position I would put there. Andersson and Chytil have chemistry and so do Necas and Chytil.





Carolina is a borderline playoff team.. most likely won't be a top 10 pick and will fall somewhere 12-17. Necas was a number 12 pick. Zucc's fair value is definitely a 1st rounder in that range, necas for hayes and vesey is a fair trade (if not a slight overpayment). That's what i was thinking with JT, unlikely yes but there is still a chance. If/When rangers sign Kovy all that they are really missing is that elite #1 center, zib is more of a 1b center right now.



yes we jettisoned McD and Miller to tampa, but miller=namestnikov essentially. Skjei has been better than McDonagh all year, and if we can get Dahlin, NYR will be in serious contention for JT since they can offer him a 12m contract. they still have the King in net, Gregoriev looked really good in his two starts despite the losses. We have heir apparent sheshtyorkin as well as forward/defensive prospects that are very exciting (andersson, chytil, necas [from trade], day, dahlin [if we win lottery], hajek, howden, as well as 11 picks over the first three rounds in the next two years[at least 4 first rounders if not 5]) . If he signs with the rangers, they are immediate playoff contenders and once tampa runs into it's cap issues in two years (with development) we will be true contenders for the cup.</div></div>

Your analysis really just hinders on the Rangers getting Dahlin. Even if the Rangers get Dahlin, San Jose will pay Tavares boat loads more, and gives a better chance at the cup. Why would Tavares go from being surrounded by young talent and defensive liabilities in NYI, to go to supposedly more young talent and defensive liabilities? You have to at least somewhat understand that Tavares (if he even leaves NYI) WON’T sign with another team that’s rebuilding. Like, just use your common sense. I don’t even know how to phrase it better than that. San Jose will offer him the same deal, if not more, and they’ll IMMEDIATELY be stanely cup favorites. Not favorites in 2 or 3 years when Tampa hits contract issues.
Forum: Armchair-GM27 févr. 2018 à 0 h 32
Sujet: Next Year
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>JUICEBOX</b></div><div>Kovalchuk will be a Ranger next year. He currently plays on the same team as Shestyorkin, and the Rangers will outbid everyone to get a familiar face for Shesty to be comfortable out of his element when he arrives for 2019-2020 season. However, I dont see Nash coming back, Brenden Smith will probably be buried for good, and Staal is a possible buyout candidate. I would like to see Zuc play the same line with Kovalchuk</div></div>

<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>JUICEBOX</b></div><div>Kovalchuk will be a Ranger next year. He currently plays on the same team as Shestyorkin, and the Rangers will outbid everyone to get a familiar face for Shesty to be comfortable out of his element when he arrives for 2019-2020 season. However, I dont see Nash coming back, Brenden Smith will probably be buried for good, and Staal is a possible buyout candidate. I would like to see Zuc play the same line with Kovalchuk</div></div>

Also, Rykov plays with Shesty and Buch has also played with him. Don’t need to worry about a familiar face in the locker room. Plus that’s not until 2020 at the latest.
Forum: Armchair-GM27 févr. 2018 à 0 h 30
Sujet: Next Year
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>JUICEBOX</b></div><div>I think you're right about Skjei, probably more in the 4m a year range depending on years. Nash WILL 100% make 4 mil though and Kovalchuk is going to be around 4-5m. Nash at 4 mil is just about half price of his existing contract. Remember he is a UFA and can take the highest offer, and this is the year u want to be a UFA as the cap is expected to go up as much as 7mil. All those teams that were interested in him at the deadline can now get him with a half off tag and not have to give up anything in return...its happening.</div></div>

Yeah but if he’s coming back to the Rangers, they just won’t pay him that. Nor will the Rangers give Kovy that either unless they’re really trying to compete which I think is the wrong move. Nash would definitely take a hometown discount. He loves NY and wants to stay here. Cashing on the highest contract probably doesn’t matter to him. Similar to Shattenkirk and his situation. He wants to play for NY and if they give him 4 mil a year, then that’s basically guaranteeing a Zuc trade in order to sign Buchnevich to a long contract.