SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

DocArin0

Membre depuis
15 déc. 2018
Équipe favorite
Maple Leafs de Toronto
Deuxième équipe favorite
Flames de Calgary
Messages dans les forums
735
Messages par jour
0.4
Forum: Armchair-GM19 févr. 2020 à 15 h 24
Sujet: Leaf Fans overreacting but
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Godfried</b></div><div>You guys are so off. Nurse and Bouchard have more value alone than either one of dermott or kapanen alone. So why would they do this. Oilers wouldnt even do nurse or Bouchard for both. Just ridiculous. Kapanen is worse Larsson and JP. Maybe get a 2nd max as well. Stop over valuing leafs players. Bouchard projects way higher than any of these guys. Wow.</div></div>

Takes 2 to overvalue. You are telling us that Kap is maybe a 2nd max while hes a Top 9 Forward on a solid contract? Have you actually seen the deals in the past week? Bottom Middle pair UFA's are worth 2 2nds atm. Coleman just got an A grade prospect &amp; a 1st while having similar numbers to Kapanen??? You are telling leaf fans to stop over valuing players while as an Oiler fan are over valuing your players????
Forum: Armchair-GM17 févr. 2020 à 21 h 43
Sujet: Fun ACGM with the Market set
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>MG1986</b></div><div>I am not going to comment on the specifics of your deal, because I think your description outlines that this is just a rough sketch type of situation. I will say though that if the Leafs could acquire a pick and a 1st for Barrie, they should 100% do it. I think he'd be good on a team like Vegas, where they have the defensive systems, and defensive-minded defenders to support him in a way the Leafs cannot. As for Evan Bouchard, I think the Oilers are being extra cautious with him, because of what happened with JP, but they have Philip Broberg, and this is the year for them to do something significant. It may not be Kapanen, but I think Evan Bouchard is definitely in play, whether Oilers fan can accept that, or not, is a different story. Finally, Andreas Johnsson. In theory it'd be nice to see what his market value is, but you have to see his injury recovery through 100% first.</div></div>

Looking back I feel this would be About right for Barrie. Realistically him in a sweat heart deal IMO the Defense version of Coleman who fetched an A grade prospect and a 1st I’d be interested to see what you feel his value is in the market compared to that?
Forum: Armchair-GM13 févr. 2020 à 13 h 25
Sujet: Dumba trade to Toronto
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>TMLSage</b></div><div>Yes, that is true but the cost is too high in that Liljegren is a right hand defenceman with huge upside and will be playing years after Dumba retires and Mikheyev who is a young forward with huge upside while Dumba is an expensive older defenceman who plays good offense but poor defence and appears to be starting his decline curve as an NHL defenceman.</div></div>

This is what i dont understand of other Leaf fans, everyone wants a Top 4 RHD. But you are not willing to give anything of actual value back. You want Dumba but you only are willing to give a 2nd round pick at most. If you want something of value you need to exchange something of value. 1 1/2 Years of Muzzin was worth a 1st, a Top 9 Prospect and a Solid Junior prospect. What do you actually think 3 1/2 Years of Dumba is going to cost you LESS? I can tell you now the price STARTS with Liljegren (Top 4 Defence prospect) &amp; at least a Top 9 Junior prospect or a 1st/2nd
Forum: Armchair-GM9 févr. 2020 à 21 h 8
Sujet: Montreal as buyers
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>GMs</b></div><div>Would you do Liljegren + 1st for Toffoli ? MTL are not trading Brook alone for Toffoli. If you don’t know the other teams prospect and needs, don’t do trades then, or you can do and we’ll let you know what’s wrong</div></div>

While i appreciate you being able to "kinda?" steer me in the right direction Brook from the outside evaluation seems like your standard #5/6 Prospect on TOR i would say hes pretty identical to RH Dermot. He was a 2 year over age in Junior with awesome stats but as should be expected when you are 20 years old in Junior playing 15-18 year olds. Was a Late 2nd in 2017 overall slightly above average numbers in the AHL this year. Like to me Brooks like like a solid prospect but nothing where you say "Man this guy is going to be in our Top 4 for sure"

As for MTLs needs i think its pretty clear they need a Solid Top 9 forward and for sure without a doubt a backup goaltender that can play 20-30 games a season.