Quoting: Black61
https://twitter.com/JFreshHockey/status/1744842893913653570?lang=en
Using a top 10 pick on a replacement level defense player whos never had 70 point seems like a bad investment.
He is always going to be a guy who you cant rely on as a top line player because he cant play against other teams best lines. He will and already does get destroyed.
Atleast with somepne like Catton or helenius even if they they end up as a 50ish point guy they can atleast be versatile enough to not have to shelter like crazy
... you know he's freaking 22 years old right? You know that players of his style don't become more responsible defensively before the age of 24 right?
Not every guy can play defensively right off the bat in the NHL. This is all tied to coaching and player's acceptance of their style and ability to get convinced that they need to improve certain aspects. As they get more experienced, as they get a bit older, they tend to stop relying on just their offensive skills and start looking at how they play. Otherwise, the team will put them with more defensive style players and let them have their go at it.
But to say he'll always be this or that.. He's 22... He's got 2 to 3 years of development still to go. The only reason I see fit that ANA would trade him out, would be because of the contract negotiations that happened to add strain to the org.. If they can get a 1st round pick, a couple of good prospects and an experienced player, would they think about it? I'm not talking about my trade, just from any other team that would put their assets on the table.
As for mine, I think Beck, Harris, Kovacevic, a first and a veteran in Pearson would be the assets Habs would put out there for him. Not saying it would get him, just saying it's what I'd give..