EDM says no.

You would have to take the 3rd away for the value to be more fair. Even then, EDM should be adding at RW or RD anyways, not LW. If they plan on spending those assets they can do so in a way that better suits their current roster construction.

No thanks to the Smith trade. No chance in hell we should be retaining on him at all, let alone for that underwhelming return. If we’re moving him, I’d much rather just deal him away without retention for a pick and then utilize the cap space toward a separate deal.

Holloway I can’t see being in the conversation. Broberg is a tough one I am fairly confident oilers organization doesn’t want to move and does have a plan in place but wouldn’t say as untouchable as Holloway.

vegas says yes