Athletic SJ Pipeline Ranking Vs Mine

Forums/Mock-Draft

Page 1 de 1

Cuvée de repêchage: 2023

Publié: 31 août 2023 à 11 h 41

Description

This is Corey Pronman's NHL Pipeline Ranking for the Sharks (left) vs Mine (right)

Honestly I don't think Corey knows anything about any of these players. He's referencing scouting reports and stats that are years old. Like Gushchin is listed at 5' 8" - 165 lbs when hes actually 5'10" - 180 lbs. I think he generally undervalues a ton of these players. Eklund being "Bubble top and middle of the lineup" is pretty far off imo. Also Tristan Robins being a longshot NHL player even though he literally got called up due to how well he was playing in the AHL last year makes no sense. And he has the Sharks 7th rounder from the LAST DRAFT as the 13th best prospect lol. I actually really like that pick but there's no way you can say they're a top prospect until at least a year after their draft year, especially a guy playing in the Russian Junior league

REPÊCHAGE

TEXTE INTÉGRÉ

Ronde 1
1. Will Smith (Blackhawks de Chicago) (Détails: 1. Will Smith 
- This is easy).
0. William Eklund (Ducks d'Anaheim) (Détails: 2. William Eklund 
- Another Easy one although Corey has him projected as middle of lineup which I think is far off).
0. Shakir Mukhamadullin (Blue Jackets de Columbus) (Détails: 3. Shakir Mukhamadullin
- I Agree here as well, extremely underrated prospect - High floor with fairly high ceiling).
0. Filip Bystedt (Sharks de San Jose) (Détails: 4. Quentin Musty 
- First spot I disagree with - I think Musty could be a legit superstar - extremely skilled, amazing shot, and big).
5. Quentin Musty (Canadiens de Montréal) (Détails: 5. Thomas Bordeleau
- For whatever reason media and the fanbase soured on Bordsdespite being an AHL allstar - Still very smart playerwith extremely good hands and edges and a vastly improving shot).
0. Thomas Bordeleau (Coyotes de l'Arizona) (Détails: 6. Daniil Gushchin 
- Probably the most impressive player growth I've seen over one season. Extremely skilled, great skater, and INSANE shot).
0. Cameron Lund (Flyers de Philadelphie) (Détails: 7. Henry Thrun
-Didn't look out of place in the NHL at all and has a fantastic skill set and looks to be very defensively responsible).
0. Henry Thrun (Capitals de Washington) (Détails: 8. Filip Bystedt
- I like Bystedt a lot but I don't see his ceiling being any higher than Danault - I think he gets a bit overrated but still a steal at 27 ovr).
9. Kasper Halttunen (Red Wings de Detroit) (Détails: 9. Mattias Havalid 
- He could be a truly talented top pairing d-man but injuries have set him back a bit).
0. Mattias Havelid (Blues de St-Louis) (Détails: 10. Tristen Robins
- Corey had him in the "has a chance to play" section. Meanwhile he had a fantastic season in the AHL and literally played a handful of NHL games.).
11. Luca Cagnoni (Canucks de Vancouver) (Détails: 11. Luca Cagnoni
- Could be a huge steal. Small but strong, really offensively gifted and has room for improvement defensively. projected to go around mid-to-late 2nd round and dropped to the 4th).
0. Daniil Gushchin (Coyotes de l'Arizona from Sénateurs d'Ottawa) (Détails: 12. Kasper Halttunen
- This is where I trust the scouts Because I don't know much about him but a lot of people say that he could really break out and become a steal from this draft).
13. Yegor Rimashevsky (Sabres de Buffalo) (Détails: 13. Ethan Cardwell
- Had a great year in Juniors. may not have a high ceiling but by all accounts is an absolute workhorse and a leader. I could definitely see him being a Barclay Goodrow type player).

Repêchage simulé généré par un utilisateur de CapFriendly.com

RONDE 1	ÉQUIPE	ORIGINAL	JOUEUR	DéTAILS

1	-	Will Smith (+3 )	1. Will Smith - This is easy
2	-	William Eklund	2. William Eklund - Another Easy one although Corey has him projected as middle of lineup which I think is far off
3	-	Shakir Mukhamadullin	3. Shakir Mukhamadullin - I Agree here as well, extremely underrated prospect - High floor with fairly high ceiling
4	-	Filip Bystedt	4. Quentin Musty - First spot I disagree with - I think Musty could be a legit superstar - extremely skilled, amazing shot, and big
5	-	Quentin Musty (+21 )	5. Thomas Bordeleau - For whatever reason media and the fanbase soured on Bordsdespite being an AHL allstar - Still very smart playerwith extremely good hands and edges and a vastly improving shot
6	-	Thomas Bordeleau	6. Daniil Gushchin - Probably the most impressive player growth I've seen over one season. Extremely skilled, great skater, and INSANE shot
7	-	Cameron Lund	7. Henry Thrun -Didn't look out of place in the NHL at all and has a fantastic skill set and looks to be very defensively responsible
8	-	Henry Thrun	8. Filip Bystedt - I like Bystedt a lot but I don't see his ceiling being any higher than Danault - I think he gets a bit overrated but still a steal at 27 ovr
9	-	Kasper Halttunen (+27 )	9. Mattias Havalid - He could be a truly talented top pairing d-man but injuries have set him back a bit
10	-	Mattias Havelid	10. Tristen Robins - Corey had him in the "has a chance to play" section. Meanwhile he had a fantastic season in the AHL and literally played a handful of NHL games.
11	-	Luca Cagnoni (+112 )	11. Luca Cagnoni - Could be a huge steal. Small but strong, really offensively gifted and has room for improvement defensively. projected to go around mid-to-late 2nd round and dropped to the 4th
12		Daniil Gushchin	12. Kasper Halttunen - This is where I trust the scouts Because I don't know much about him but a lot of people say that he could really break out and become a steal from this draft
13	-	Yegor Rimashevsky (+190 )	13. Ethan Cardwell - Had a great year in Juniors. may not have a high ceiling but by all accounts is an absolute workhorse and a leader. I could definitely see him being a Barclay Goodrow type player
14	-
15	-
16	-
17
18	-
19
20	-
21	-
22
23	-
24
25
26
27	-
28
29
30	-
31
32	-

31 août 2023 à 12 h 23

NoVaSpartan

Craig Laughlin Fan

Rejoint: nov. 2019

Messages: 5,322

Mentions "j'aime": 5,746

Bordeleau feels like a similar media narrative to Lapierre, where both had brief NHL stints but despite both having decent AHL seasons the next year, the prospect experts decide that they've somehow had some large fall from grace. Feels like impatience from people.

Rob32sjsharks a aimé ceci.

31 août 2023 à 13 h 56

Rob32sjsharks

Rejoint: avr. 2020

Messages: 11,286

Mentions "j'aime": 4,687

I think you have to add Laroque and Fisher. Both had injury marred seasons but both have shown a TON of upside and I feel at least 1 will become a legit NHL top 4 D

Weisblatt and Coe both should factor in more next season, they both have upside but look like depth NHL if they can take another step or two.

Répondre

Page 1 de 1

PARAMÈTRES D’AFFICHAGE

COTES DES PARIS

LANGUE

ARCHIVES

CBA

CALCS

OUTILS - FANTASY HOCKEY

OUTILS

JOUEURS

CONFÉRENCE DE L'OUEST

CONFÉRENCE DE L'EST

OUTILS INTERACTIFS

Forums/Mock-Draft