I would be stuck between Dubnyk and Price, but I'd go with Price

My top 5 goalies in order

Price
Holtby
Lundqvist
Dubnyk
Bishop

I think the best goalie in the league is Bob.

Edit: By 'Bob' i mean Bobrovsky in case you didn't understand what i meant.

Are we basing this on this year, last 3 years, career? What is this based on because I could vote 3 different ways just based on my example time frames

I'm pretty sure it's whatever you'd rather have. Like, if you, yourself, think it's based off this year only, then vote for that ... if you think it's based off the last few years, vote for the guy you think has been the best in the last few years. So it depends who you are.