I like the take on this. Also I really like the Gagner signing, but that's as an Oilers fan.
I must ask, how come Gagner is above Connor Brown? Connor Brown is much better. Does he have better chemistry on line 3?
Speaking of chemistry, though at the moment I agree Norris is better than Stutzle, do you think Stutzle should be on line 1?

Note: this is the worst case scenario. So I would not love the Gagner signing, specially if it forces Brown down the lineup. Leads into question two: Brown is better and is a good fit for the top 6.

Stutzle, I think, will be the more complete player eventually. Norris is on the verge of of a 30 goal season and is better defensively in only his 2nd NHL season. Doesn't help that Stutzle has very little to work with beside him as the LW, Formenton, is finding his finish and whomever on the RW side right now is no good. Hoping we see a Formenton-Stutzle-Joseph line.