Quoting: redw1n9s
You cannot compare Duchene to Stepan. You just cannot. Duchene is a top 3 pick and an elite player in the NHL. He's just on a bad team. Stepan is a middle 6 center; he's good but he's not comparable in any way. The Rangers are adding value with a 5th? And a good prospect? This is not even close - in terms of value or what the Avs are looking for.
Not comparable at all? I'm not a Stepan supporter at all but I can willingly see comparables where your choosing not to. Both centres. Both number 1 centres on their respective teams with Mack taking over for Duchene now. both put up multiple 50+ pt seasons. Both can play in all situations. Both same age. Both same height and weight approx.....etc fracking etc.
I love Duchene and I agree he is the better player between the two but considering his numbers over his career are not that spectacular and the fact that a team is actively looking at trading him even though he's still in his prime goes to show that he does not hold water with some of the true number 1 centres in the league. He's a notch below. That's still really really good but he is being over hyped. Stepan is not as good as Duchene. I agree with this but is he really that
far off? The stats don't show that. The minutes used don't show that. Contract doesn't show that. The underlying numbers don't show that.
So tell where exactly can you show me that he is so far off its not even close? You can't. You just like jump on the Duchene is the best player in the league bandwagon like so many else do.
Once again this trade does not make sense for the AVS. They are looking for defensive help not a replacement for Duchene so this trade would only prove to be lateral at best. Which serves no purpose. But if we're talking just value intensive purposes, yeah its not that
far off. Its closer then you think. That doesn't change the fact that the Avs shouldn't do it.