You hate the leafs though

nah, not the team, it's their fans that at times get annoying (dont mean the people at capfriendly mostly) admitting them setting new records on highest cap comparables for young players is also really annoying
so no favors being done there

i'm a jets fan i if i could pick between who i would rather want i'll take Eichel.. main reason because he does more considering the team around him

for example u remove Matthews and Eichel from their teams, Toronto still has a pretty good team, around wild card, but Buff is easily a lottery team, shows what both of them play with

not the best way a compare them but their both so comparable everywhere really, this a pretty good difference maker i think

It's very close but I'd love to see what people would say if Eichel was a Leaf and Matthews was a Sabre

Why are y'all debating Eichel vs Matthews? The answer's pretty obvious
Kesler haha