no idc how good hall we are not trading quinn

How about Nico for Edler

appreciate the sarcasm, very clearly not the same thing

Just as realistic

not quite

since i have the time ill spell it out

edler is 6 years older, hes a pretty good defenseman. I'm not sure he's ever been the best on his team nevermind the nhl
Hall is one of the leagues top players, posesses a hart trophy and drives play. so right there its not even comparable.

Next is you're saying replace quinn with nico. i think quinn has a higher ceiling so yeah I wouldnt do one for one if i was van, also d have more value i think

in my offer it was hall and a first and mueller, maybe its not enough prob not based on what they see in hughes so far. maybe instead of mueller its boqvist or bratt to make it really have a chance.

you claiming my proposal is equal to nico for edler is dumb and for whatever reason i'm dumb enough to actually respond and no it is not as realistic. as my trade has a legitimate basis and could prove as a start even if too low initially. yours is a non starter

Just as realistic