Blues say no.

Remove the third?

Still not remotely close. We have no use for either of those players.

You lose a year of Allen's contract for a debatable better goaltender. You take a slight decrease on the defense for a more physical guy. Boro can be moved later. Value wise, it probably is fair without the third.

Dude. Value-wise, it's not even close. Eddy is plenty physical and that's not something we lack back there anyway. You're also either underselling Allen or overselling Anderson. We are not dealing away Eddy to spend $5M on a 38-yo meh back-up goalie we let walk for free 13 years ago.