spooner for a 2nd rounder seems low

yeah but to avoid any harsh critic because i would like a late first rounder, i went with what he would DEFINITELY get

No it doesn't.

Dallas doesn't have the cap to make that deal, nor would they trade Heiskanen for that package.

41 points in 59 games? about .7ppg

last 3 seasons

41 points in 59 games
39 points in 78 games
49 points in 80 games

example trade

tatar last 3 seasons
34 points in 82 games
28 in 62 games
46 in 82 games

very close id say spooner is better......tatar value in a trade......1st 2nd and a 3rd......so yeah his value should be more than a 2nd

tatar also was part of a trade that brought patches to Vegas......haha I'm very interested in how you claim he's worth only a 2nd?

tatar with worst stats got a 1st 2nd and 3rd rounder

Tatar brought in a 1st, 2nd, and 3rd because Vegas overpaid, so you can't use that as a basis. As for Spooner, no, those numbers don't equal a first rounder.

So the rumor is true? Karlsson is Russian?

so in your opinion they overpaid? ha great point

okay how bout skinner who is slightly better but a ufa/one year rental
Cliff Pu · $0 (AHL/JR) (69th pick in 2016)
2019 2nd round pick
2020 3rd round pick
2020 6th round pick

last season skinner had 49 points in 82 games
spooner had 41points in 59 games

or does this one not count either? haha

It is actually the opinion of many people, so nice try.

If you don't see that Skinner has accomplished much more than Spooner has, I don't know what else to tell you. So save the snarky BS comments for somebody else.

I guess I was waiting for you to support your claim or give an example of how other players with similar numbers received more......

wow.. that's pretty cheeky of you.. guess you didn't see the 19474910 russians on the team

Canes should have gotten a better deal for Skinner. Again, that is not just my opinion, but that of lots of people.
I'm a Devils fan. We have a guy you used to root for named Marcus Johanssson. He has a bit better numbers than Spooner and he only cost us a 2nd and a 3rd. If he's not worth a first, Spooner sure isn't.

he benefitted a lot from being on the #1 pp unit he was a major turnover machine and was constantly injured but thank you for giving a good example......also congrats on the hall trade

honestly though the caps should have let Vegas take mojo and kept Schmidt ......his value was way more than what they got

Bar none, the biggest expansion draft blunder was the Jackets. Handing over a 1st and Wild Bill Karlsson to take on Clarkson's contract and not choose Jack Johnson or Josh Anderson in the expansion. Turns out we didn't even want to resign Johnson and Karlsson is 5 times better than Anderson based on stats alone (let alone position need).
Oh well, hindsight is 20/20 (except for the blind, it is 20/200).

They definitely should have kept Schmidt. I hate that his numbers last season are now being attributed to cheating rather than the increased opportunities he got with Vegas.

hold my beer......... forsberg for erat and latta......not a draft related thing but still terrible

haha right for a grain of salt in a swimming pool size specimen found? thats crazy.......like mike Richards was arrested for driving coke or something like that and played the next season.....nhl has a weird way of coming down on players

Rangers Luc Robitaille traded to the Los Angeles Kings for Kevin Stevens, Rangers traded Doug Weight to the Edmonton Oilers for Esa Tikkanen, Rangers traded Tony Amonte to the Chicago Blackhawks with Matt Oates for Brian Noonan and Stephane Matteau. I'm dating myself a bit but yeah-- idk if anything beats these

Ah yes, the old school days when half the league still played without helmets.

Do the Rangers win that Cup with Amonte instead of Matteau, though? ? Excuse me, painful memories.

I believe the capitals refused to pay Scott Stevens and let him walk for 4 1st rounders ....maybe less not 100% sure