Dale Tallon would be fired on the spot if he made that trade. Florida receives NOTHING of substance for their best player. Can we trade Carl Hagelin and Tom Kuhnhackl for McDavid too?

Florida isn't moving Trocheck, and if they were, you can likely expect Guentzel or Maatta needing to be included in the deal to have a shot, along with a high pick and a prospect like Sprong or Jarry.

If Florida were in a complete rebuild mode I wouldn't think you are too far off (move one of those picks to a 1, add a better prospect) but they aren't..