Good for both side... But change for MTL 2nd as Galch= Saad + 4th and Forsling for 2nd (No #38)

I think the Hawks are giving up too much in this deal. They might trade Saad for Chucky straight up but no way they throw Forsling in too. The Hawks aren't giving up on Saad this quickly either.

One down season and everyone wants to trade Saad for a less well-rounded player? I really like Galchenyuk but he's not exactly an all star defensively, and when both are on, Saad puts up the same or better numbers more consistently than Chucky. Chicago certainly wouldn't need to add in Forsling, one of their more NHL ready young d-men, even if Chucky is a bit cheaper.

There is no way I trade Saad..........A lot of you guys are too impatient.. Saad isn't the problem so why trade him? the Hawks need to add players not subtract players and there is nothing wrong with Saad..... The Hawks didn't have the right players this season which is why they failed... The Hawks need to add some experienced veteran depth forward defenisve specialists, they need a top 4 defenseman, a 2nd line LW and a legitimate backup goalie..... If Bowman can do that the Hawks will be contending for a cup next spring..

The only way Bowman trades Saad is if he's made an offer he just couldn't refuse, and I think right now that would have to be a lot.... Like a top 10 pick, top prospect and top 6 forward or top 4 defenseman and I just cant see a team offering that for Saad right now...

Don't forget that Bowman gave up a significant asset in Panarin to bring Saad back and I can't see Bowman just trading Saad after only 1 year - especially when we all know what Saad is capable of..... If Bowman traded Saad for anything less than a massive over payment I would have to think that would be a fireable offense...