Maybe it's just me, but I think SJS is giving up a bit too much for Shatty, unless you get him signed to an extension. Goldobin/Meier + Mueller + 1st/2nd would be more than fair. It's refreshing to, at least, see someone overpay for a good player, rather than do one of the following (that hockeycap posters seem to do 10 times out of 9):

1.) severely underpay for a good player
2.) severely overpay for a decent player
3.) trade rape the shit out of a team for their star player, and then get all butt hurt when people start to make fun of their terrible arm-chair GM.

Thanks for that - appreciate the feedback. I've updated the trade proposal to one that has SJ give up less (not because they're my team - just trying to find the most fair value-for-value deal).