New York Islanders 18-19 Team

Very ambitious effort for your first try, so I'm giving you four stars for that. Each of your trades should be considered in isolation, because if one of them went through, the Isles would not make the other two because nobody trades away their first-round picks three years in a row unless they're getting Marner and Nylander from the Leafs. But here's my biggest criticism: it's sep-A-rate, not sep-E-rate.

Haha, you're right on the separate thing... can't believe I missed that!!! As for the not trading away three 1st RD picks in a row in the same year... I don't know about that. I've read Lou has no problems trading picks away if it means getting proven talent. Plus, all guys acquired are either signed long term or agree to long term deals upon being acquired. Plus the Isles could move Eberle at the deadline to re-coup some picks if they feel Wahlstrom is ready to step in full time next year.

But thank you for your opinion and feedback!!!

I like the ideas but I think the Isles overpaid in all of the trades you created. No way Klefbom is worth Pelech + 1st + more. Also, Nelson, Ho-Sang, AND a 1st for Duchene? Seems like a bit much.

I like the lineup though.

Hmm, okay, I can see that. I was mostly going off what's been rumored to be asking prices for some of these guys. I guess in some spots the 1st Rd picks can be swapped out for 2nd or 3rd picks.... Thanks for the feedback! Much appreciated!

I like the aggressiveness and like the others said, you gave up too much for each. That also means that you'd still have better players and/or more picks left so it'd look even better. That being said though, I wouldn't trade Anders Lee unless he refuses to extend this season. We've learned that lesson already, obviously. Also, we wouldn't be able to keep all of these players. Personally, I think Panarin is going to go to free agency and purely take the most money from whatever team offers him the moon.