all in

Change Smith for Tuch and add another 1st

I understand the principle of the Eichel trade you're trying to make, but it needs a little more value. I only see Reilly Smith being there to make the cap work, especially considering his drop in production last season and his expiring contract, so that makes him essentially a wash. I think Buffalo would want another quality prospect and a high draft pick to have this go through.

Hawks would need more (and give up less) to take Fleury. Great goalie no doubt but the Hawks aren't contending and he would be a waste here.

Then add a first. not giving up Tuch and Krebs