Mantha

As a Wings fan, that is a very interesting trade.

Agreed, Mantha is a good prospect but Holland has deemed him not worthy of this terrible Detroit lineup so I'd like to get a Dman instead

The Wings need a good shakeup. Maybe a trade can spark something good.

Value is good and return intriguing to say the least, but it leaves the Ducks seriously thin at RD with Manson, Bieksa, and NHL untested Montour (Wolford has Theo at RD but he plays left and is left handed). Trading Cam would make more sense as both Theo and Larsson look more prepared to play in the NHL full-time, but again neither are really ready to be top 4 Dmen yet. Makes more sense to play out the year as-is on defense to give the kids another year to develop, then make a trade to shed weight. Getz, Perry, and Kes are getting too old to throw away a year of defense when there's no need

I like the Det trade a lot. I'd be more interested in seeing Mantha play next to Getzlaf and Perry though.