SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

GirouxFanclub

Membre depuis
11 mai 2021
Équipe favorite
Flyers de Philadelphie
Messages dans les forums
294
Messages par jour
0.3
Forum: Armchair-GM2 juin 2021 à 14 h 22
Forum: Armchair-GM2 juin 2021 à 13 h 36
Sujet: Give Me Your Thoughts Dallas Fans
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>SlevinKalevra</b></div><div>Stars are going for it this coming season. I don’t see them letting Pavs go. Seattle probably takes Dickie. Honestly I’d prefer they leave Faksa exposed for cap and roster flexibility purposes, but I’m realistic about who the GM is. Dobby for futures is very likely assuming they’re comfortable with Bishop’s health. Nill wants Oleksiak back and I think he is a better fit for the system than Murray. Would love to have Daddy back. I feel like him and Sekera would be the third pair as Harley still needs some work on his defensive game. I’d love to see him in from the start, but I’m realistic about who the coach is.</div></div>

If they bring Pavelski back for one more year would it still be smart to sign Saad to add more scoring depth?
Forum: Armchair-GM2 juin 2021 à 12 h 8
Forum: Armchair-GM2 juin 2021 à 11 h 55
Sujet: Jones and Lindholm
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>ChiHawk</b></div><div>We need a vet D man entering his prime on the left side, matching Murphy anchoring on the right...both defensive D men. For that reason, I'd go hard at Lindholm and pass on Jones. Saad over Hyman at that price. That leaves another $5M on the table for next year over this AGM for total cap space of roughly $12M which is pretty much where the Hawks need to be for next year.

Kubalik - Toews - Saad
Cat - Dach - Kane
Hagel - Suter - Hino
Entwistle/Borgstrom - Kampf - Carps

Lindholm - BoQ
Keith - Murphy
Kalynuk - Mitchell</div></div>

I'm just not sure if it's worth it to sell some of your future for a d-man that will have his prime basically wasted in the middle of a rebuild if that makes sense. Ik where you are coming from tho bc its harder for younger players to develop if they are not playing with anybody good to make it easier for them.
Forum: Armchair-GM2 juin 2021 à 11 h 45
Sujet: Jones and Lindholm
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>ChiHawk</b></div><div>Prime years for a defensive player is usually between 28 and 30, later then a forward. Both players are entering their prime years.

I'd be hesitant on giving that much for Jones. He had a subpar season last season so there is a risk there. Given that he has already said he will be a UFA and re-sign with Colombus, I don't think he will get quite that much with the flat cap. There will be bidders for sure, but think Strome, Mitchell a 1st and 4th should get him with an extension. Without, Strome and Mitchell should be enough.

Hampus Lindholm is my favorite because he would be a great future pairing with BoQ given both their strengths and weaknesses. With an extension in place, I think he will get a bit more then you offered here, but without a bit less.

Move De Haan as he's not part of the future. Perhaps Guadette and he would be an attractive offer to someone. Kalynuk should be playing 3rd pairing in that scenario with Stillman as the 7th man.

Hyman is interesting, not sure I'm completely bought in on him at that price, which is likely very close to what he will cost. I'd also love to see a line of Hagel - Suter and Hinostroza...that line with that speed and pestering and talent could wreak havoc on the opposing teams 3rd and 4th lines. Entwistle, among a couple others could play 4th line. Borstrom being another option. You could move Kubalik or Debrincat to the right side and move hyman up and knock Reichel down, but I'm high on Reichel and think after a short stint in the AHL he will be brought up permanently which then he needs space.

For all these reasons, Hyman to me is unnecessary with a crowded bottom 9 up front already although I understand the intent. To me, I would rather sign Saad then Hyman. Hyman has no doubt been a benefactor of playing with Matthews and Marner so his stats are bit padded and Saad you could say the same although he playing very very close this season's stats on the Hawks. Saad also is a north south good defensive player, tough on the boards, and has speed...all IMO a bit better then Hyman. For the same price, if you wanted to add a top 6 guy, I'd go Saad over Hyman if possible.

Good post overall though</div></div>

<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>ChiHawk</b></div><div>Prime years for a defensive player is usually between 28 and 30, later then a forward. Both players are entering their prime years.

I'd be hesitant on giving that much for Jones. He had a subpar season last season so there is a risk there. Given that he has already said he will be a UFA and re-sign with Colombus, I don't think he will get quite that much with the flat cap. There will be bidders for sure, but think Strome, Mitchell a 1st and 4th should get him with an extension. Without, Strome and Mitchell should be enough.

Hampus Lindholm is my favorite because he would be a great future pairing with BoQ given both their strengths and weaknesses. With an extension in place, I think he will get a bit more then you offered here, but without a bit less.

Move De Haan as he's not part of the future. Perhaps Guadette and he would be an attractive offer to someone. Kalynuk should be playing 3rd pairing in that scenario with Stillman as the 7th man.

Hyman is interesting, not sure I'm completely bought in on him at that price, which is likely very close to what he will cost. I'd also love to see a line of Hagel - Suter and Hinostroza...that line with that speed and pestering and talent could wreak havoc on the opposing teams 3rd and 4th lines. Entwistle, among a couple others could play 4th line. Borstrom being another option. You could move Kubalik or Debrincat to the right side and move hyman up and knock Reichel down, but I'm high on Reichel and think after a short stint in the AHL he will be brought up permanently which then he needs space.

For all these reasons, Hyman to me is unnecessary with a crowded bottom 9 up front already although I understand the intent. To me, I would rather sign Saad then Hyman. Hyman has no doubt been a benefactor of playing with Matthews and Marner so his stats are bit padded and Saad you could say the same although he playing very very close this season's stats on the Hawks. Saad also is a north south good defensive player, tough on the boards, and has speed...all IMO a bit better then Hyman. For the same price, if you wanted to add a top 6 guy, I'd go Saad over Hyman if possible.

Good post overall though</div></div>

<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>GirouxFanclub</b></div><div>Does not make any sense for chicago's timeline. All there building pieces are like 19-23 years old why trade for defensman who will be 30-33 by the time your rebuild is over.</div></div>

^^^^ above is why I don't think it makes much sense for Chicago