If you want honest opinion you’ve come to the right website…

A lot of movement to basically trade Engvall + Holl for Timmins. Couldn’t you just do that directly?

Main issue with the Oilers trade is that they have a plethora of LW so Engvall is not worth a 2nd to them. And Barrie is worth more than Holl so the trade doesnt make sense for the Oilers.

Timmins has more value to the Yotes than Barrie and throw in picks. I want Dubas's pups to be homeward bound(sorry, Iykyk), but this doesn't really line up with their tanking.

I would not touch Barrie. In This market he would have zero value if not negative.

The trade with the oilers is senseless. I don't think there is a scenario where I would move Holl and Engvall for such little value. That Said I would like to see the leafs pick up Timmins. As a reclamation project. I've always liked him and I would like to see him healthy.