SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

chuck28

Membre depuis
18 juill. 2016
Messages dans les forums
349
Messages par jour
0.1
Forum: Armchair-GM21 mai 2023 à 0 h 18
Forum: Armchair-GM28 déc. 2022 à 3 h 44
Sujet: Summer retool
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>AG_sweden</b></div><div>All MTL players they are trying to get rid off (because they are not good but wont admit to being bad) is all worth first round pick, they think. And all players they want (because they are good, but can't admit to that either) is worth close to nothing. Just accept that it is that way. All of this is for fun and has nothing to do with reality.</div></div>

We thought Chiarot was only worth a 1st round pick. He was worth more
We thought Lehkonen was worth a 2nd +, not a RHD prospect drafted in the 1st round on top of the 2nd round pick
We thought Kulak could get us a 3rd at best, we got a 2nd + 7th round pick
Romanov + 4th round pick got us the 13th OA
Because of those trades, we might overvalue the worth of our players. Kent Hughes fault
Forum: Armchair-GM25 déc. 2022 à 9 h 52
Sujet: habs 22-23 TDL hope
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>chuck28</b></div><div>thanks for the feed back

so basicaly its just Edmunson that we don't get along for the value

Drouin,Dadonov, Hoffman for 4/5 round if retain is around mid to late (but we could only retain on one if we retain on Monahan and Edmunson)
so we can accept 6/7 round with no retention or
i agree with you and have no problem to just wait till the end for Drouin and Dadonov (this summer) that's why i said 3 on 5
and Monhan half retain for a 1st round that's what we want i add a grade B prospect in the trade but the possibility to add on MTL side too to compensate but Monahan for a 1st straigt up i am ok with it

but i think with 2 years of retain salary on Edmunson if we add a mid round (or value of) we can get a 1st OR a good prospect

so i am not too far off overall</div></div>

Edmundson with retention + '23 4th should = late 1st from EDM... would they do it? maybe...

It's only worth a '23 3rd to add a B prospect in Monahan deal if it's a D or G, so find them on those teams and propose trade to see feedback

Edmundson to LA at 50% might be interesting for them.
Forum: Armchair-GM10 déc. 2022 à 11 h 0
Sujet: Stars Deadline
The trade value for Monahan, if healthy, seems spot on. If healthy is the only question mark and if a trade were to occur, I would imagine it would happen closer to the TDL to minimize risk.
Small sample so far but Monahan has shown he is exactly what you want in a 2nd line center. Big body paired with high IQ who can sustain offensive pressure, plays on the PP and PK, excellent face off man who will take that face off with one minute left in the game, whether up one goal or down one goal, great leader. I’m not sure what’s missing if you are looking to upgrade your center position heading into the playoffs.

As for the return, it’s a lot of dead cap that Montreal would be retaining (that they could otherwise use to gain other assets from other teams), so the total return seems pretty fair.