SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

Pmatychuk13

Membre depuis
14 juill. 2021
Équipe favorite
Oilers d'Edmonton
Messages dans les forums
69
Messages par jour
0.1
Forum: Armchair-GM6 janv. à 13 h 58
Sujet: The Time is now
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>dk325</b></div><div>Campbell likely costs more than a 1st to dump alone. At best you're looking at Broberg, Savoie, and Janmark for Boone 50% retained for 2.5 years which is just not a trade any team would consider accepting. Especially not one who already has the depth that the Jackets have at LD and LW.</div></div>

Okay that's fair enough, do you think if it was two firsts in that deal they would consider? I don't follow CBJ so I'm not sure exactly what their strengths and weaknesses are, but I did hear that maybe they'll be looking at moving Provorov at the deadline potentially opening up a spot on LD. I guess it all depends also where CBJ sees themselves in their rebuild. If Jenner really is not available unless its a massive move then probably not worth it.
Forum: Armchair-GM5 oct. 2022 à 14 h 16
Sujet: Its time
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>CD282</b></div><div>They have LHD set up for 4 years already. Kulak is the 2LD until such time as Broberg surpasses him, then he's a 3LD until his contract is over. If Samorukov or Niemelainen pass him he can be traded (he doesn't have any trade protection) or moved to the right side.

Chychrun is better than Kulak, but I think Holland made his choice in the summer. He did try to land Chychrun but when Armstrong insisted Broberg be part of the deal Holland walked away and went with Kulak instead.


I don't agree with that assessment. Nemo hits a lot but often takes himself out of the play seeking big hits, and he has zero offensive instincts. Dima has been quietly effective but against mostly AHL comp, offensively he deferred almost completely to Barrie.

Plus Broberg has a much higher ceiling then either.</div></div>

I think best case scenario is Broberg turns out to be a similar level of player that Chychrun is right now so that’s where my thoughts of why not make that move to better the team while we have the window. Like you said though Holland won’t trade him so this trade doesn’t really matter. Just something for me.

I agree that Broberg has the higher ceiling for sure, but how long are you willing wait for Broberg to become that top 4 guy? All I meant was right now I don’t see Broberg being above and beyond Neimo or Samo on the depth chart, they’re all pretty close imo. Making Broberg the dispensable one if you’re upgrading the LD by trading him because he has the most value. I’d rather have Nurse Chychrun Kulak down the left side starting right now for the next 3+ years.
Forum: Armchair-GM5 oct. 2022 à 12 h 9
Sujet: Its time
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>CD282</b></div><div>As others have said, you can't move the James Neal dead money. And Holland won't trade Broberg for Chychrun.

It really doesn't make a lot of sense for Edmonton to submit the high bid for Chychrun, as they have their top-4 LHD set for the rest of the decade and they don't like playing defensemen on their offside.</div></div>


Learn something new everyday! I don’t see why Edmonton wouldn’t be going after Chychrun, other than maybe his injury history. If they added him they’d have their entire LD set for the next 3 years no question. At this point Broberg is a question mark as to what kind of player he’s going to be. Maybe he’ll be a top 4 one day but they can’t wait for him to develop. Plus Samorukov and Neimelanen can make Broberg dispensable imo. Especially right now since I think they’ve both out played him in preseason.
Forum: Armchair-GM8 juin 2022 à 17 h 6
Sujet: Off season
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>jassan28</b></div><div>Some tips I'd give on my research, McLeod contract is too high with too my term for a player that has shown a step from the AHL to the big league this year, I'd give shorter bridge deal with contract between mid 1 million. Kulak isn't my type of veteran D nor is Miller to make this roster better, the perfect name I want is someone like Nick Leddy or trade/sign from the Islanders defence corps. Miller can be really good if he shoots the puck more and continues defensive development under Manson. Husso can be signed by everyone at that price so I see his contract near 5 million give or take. Barrie won't be something a team wants so it'll be a Marleau type deal but not involving 1st rounders going the other way unless an asset comes back. Kassian can't be traded unless key Assets go the other way like a 1st round pick. Foegle isn't special unless our 2nd rounder goes rather than 3rd for Fischer and a 4th or 5th rounder</div></div>

That’s a pretty good break down. With mcleod I just figured you could maybe steal a couple years on a good contract if he continues to take steps forward, slight overpay. I think you’re wrong about Barrie, I do believe there is definitely a market out there that the oilers could get a good return on but it’s about finding the right fit for him. Husso is a bit of a hope and prayer kind of contract lol. I’m a fan of both kulak and Miller so that’s where those come from. Kassian I’m probably out to lunch on but I can’t get a gauge on what a trade would look like and Foegele in comparison to Fischer has almost always had better numbers.
Forum: Armchair-GM28 févr. 2022 à 8 h 23
Sujet: Being a GM would suck
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Tallman25</b></div><div>I can’t believe YOU people keep trading Barrie like he doesn’t have team friendly contract, if I’m trading him I’m getting something similar maybe even more if the player has more money then term, $4.5M for 3years…Steal, yes he ain’t performing like it but at the end of the day Barrie can puck handle with elite players shouldn’t be ignored at all</div></div>

I still think barrie has value on the market for sure. But at the end of the day hes been extremely poor this year. The one thing hes supposed to be an expert at hes struggled to do so imo his value at the moment has dropped a bit. If the oilers can address a goalie and atleast another D i could see them unloading barrie to free up the cap and try to retain some picks they have lost. Holland loves his draft picks. Trading him could also be an offseason move.