SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

FloridaPuck

Future GM
Membre depuis
27 mai 2021
Équipe favorite
Panthers de la Floride
Messages dans les forums
33
Messages par jour
0.0
Forum: Armchair-GM23 juin 2022 à 17 h 27
Forum: Armchair-GM23 juin 2022 à 17 h 11
Forum: Armchair-GM23 juin 2022 à 15 h 48
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Kalopsia</b></div><div>I was using SV% because I can calculate it for each series, while stats like this just give you one number for the entire playoff run. But fine, I'll use this then. Here's his GSAE in the playoffs each year and where it ranks.

13-14: -5.4 GSAE, ranked 25th out of 28

16-17: -3.0 GSAE, ranked 22nd out of 23

17-18: -3.1 GSAE, ranked 24th out of 29

18-19: 0.8 GSAE, ranked 10th out of 22

19-20: -2.3 GSAE, ranked 37th out of 42

20-21: -4.0 GSAE, ranked 23rd out of 24

21-22: 6.7 GSAE, ranked 4th out of 30

And just for fun, here's his numbers from Philly. He wasn't the full time starter for these, but here they are for completeness' sake

10-11: -2.1 GSAE, ranked 20th out of 25

11-12: -2.6 GSAE (in ONE game!), ranked 18th out of 22

So that's one good playoff run, one that was about average, and five that were absolutely awful (which includes by your measure the runs after two of his three best regular seasons), plus a smattering of terrible play in relief for Philly. All together he's at a career -15.0 GSAE in the playoffs, and I'm not gonna go to the trouble to check but I'd be shocked if anyone else has a worse career number since that website started. As I've been saying, you can't trust Bob in the postseason.</div></div>

Vasilevskiy had a -5.1 in 2019 playoffs. Playoffs just aren't enough of a sample size Bob played more games this regular season than he has in the playoffs in his career. What it comes down to is Bob is 1/2 goalies that is top 5 goalie in the nhl 3/last 6 years in GSAE and you think that you're better off with two goalies that have never had a positive GSAE in the regular season and haven't been that great in the postseason either. Also you'd only be paying 6 mil of his contract. You're crazy to think Bob is not a huge upgrade.
Forum: Armchair-GM22 juin 2022 à 23 h 13
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Kalopsia</b></div><div>Here are Bob's four best regular seasons:

2012-13: Bob has a .932 SV% and wins the Vezina, but the Jackets miss the playoffs.

2013-14: Bob has a .923 SV% and comes in 8th in Vezina voting. In the playoffs, he has a .908 SV% as the Jackets lose 4-2 to the Pens in the first round. In the elimination game he has an .857 SV% as the Jackets lose 4-3.

2016-17: Bob has a .931 SV% and wins the Vezina. In the playoffs, he has an .882 SV% as the Jackets lose 4-1 to the Pens in the first round. In the first elimination game, he has an .871 SV% but the Jackets manage to win 5-4. The next elimination game he has an .844 SV% and the Jackets lose 5-2.

2017-18: Bob has a .921 SV% and comes in 8th in Vezina voting. In the playoffs, he has a .900 SV% as the Jackets lose 4-2 to the Caps in the first round. In the elimination game he has an .815 SV% as the Jackets lose 6-3. (As a Caps fan, Bob's collapse after their OTL in game 3 was a huge reason the Caps won that series)

This is the problem with Bob. Even when he's good in the regular season he can **** the bed in the playoffs, and he seems to particularly struggle when the pressure is at his highest. His overall record in elimination games is 2-6 with an .879 SV%. Both wins were followed by a loss the next game with a sub-.900 SV%. Even when he's playing well it's just impossible to trust him.

If Bob was the only option, I'd take the Eller+Vanecek for Bob (50% retained)+Bennett deal. Fortunately there seem to be a lot of alternatives out there without his playoff baggage, and I'd hope the Caps do their due diligence on those guys first.</div></div>

Save percentage doesn’t take in to account shot quality and therefore does not show how the goalie would play independent of the defense in front of him. When looking at t goals saved above expected his best years are 2016-17, 2017-18, and 2021-22. Each of those years he saved over 20 goals above expected being ranked in the top 4 of the league. This was his best year in the playoffs. Stop using out of date metrics lol
Forum: Armchair-GM22 juin 2022 à 16 h 54
Forum: Armchair-GM22 juin 2022 à 16 h 31
Forum: Armchair-GM22 juin 2022 à 16 h 18