Steven_Dean
Rejoint: juin 2017
Messages: 144
Mentions "j'aime": 12
You are not giving up enough in either deal.
While Gallagher is a great player, he had a off year and is a clear downgrade to RNH. The other pieces are a 28 year old AHL player and a 6th. The cap relief isn't worth the big difference in value.
As for the Tatar deal it is even worse. A 6/7 defenseman in Davidson and a decent prospect but one that is looking to peak at 2nd/3rd line. Likely 3rd. Not worth Tatar at all.
I'm guessing if you want them to bite on this then Edmonton will need a decent defensive prospect and a 2nd minimum while Detroit will need an A level prospect and a 1st to get them to basically embrace a rebuild.