Absolut no from Arizona. Firstly and I can't see them trading Keller at all. Secondly Holtz + 2024 First round is just a good starting point. They would want Nemec or Luke in return.

Probably goes without saying but Luke is untouchable and Nemec is not on the table here

Name one trade in the history of the NHL where a return included a top-5 prospect, a top-10 prospect and a 1st round pick….(or even two top-25 prospects).

Take out Holtz. Replace with Casey, Clarke or Daws. Add conditional 3rd in 2026.

seems reasonable.

when in the history of the NHL has a A luke hughes/Simon nemec level prospect been traded?

Holtz is not anywhere close to a top 25 prospect. Let alone top 10

Latest ranking...McKeen's: #10
Daily Faceoff: #13
The Athletic: #22
Hockey Writers: #8
Elite Prospects: #16

Maybe you were thinking of someone else?

Of course, I can't name one,I just wanted to say that Arizona would only trade Keller for an overpay which would not happen.

Would you trade Bratt for Sharangovich, Walsh, Daws, a first and a third in 3 years?

If my team was the 2nd youngest in NHL, youngest in playoffs, youngest to 2nd round in many years…with a ton of cap space…no. I would not.

If my team was on the earlier side of a mult-year rebuild…I probably would (but would ask for Filmon over Sharangovich).

wasn't everyone saying this about chychrun?
and meier
and fiala
and debrincat
and reinhart
and eichel
and...

I like your answer, very polite. : )

Okay, you got me with your point.

considering how 200+ more players are about to be drafted, Holtz will be 22 next season, and he has yet to make an NHL impact with multiple chances, he is not going to be a top 25 prospect at the beginning of next season

In the cap era only two guys have had more productive D+2 seasons in the AHL. Rantanen and Reichel. This year, he didn’t play as much since he was part of a team that was winning more than expected. If we had known we were to have 3rd best record in league, we would have left him in AHL all year.

There is nothing on his record that has diminished his standing with evaluators. McKeens, Hockey Writers, Daily Faceoff, others have him as the top winger prospect in NHL (and Elite Prospects and The Athletic have him only behind Eklund and Reichel respectively).

Holtz will be a stud