nothing you are offering has much interest to us

Regardless of what anyone might think from the Buffalo side, I'm convinced that we would want either a 2023 first plus an A prospect or a 2024 first plus two A prospects.

To put it another way, whether we trade John Gibson isn't so much a question of value as it is a question of motivation. The fact that Gibson's contract term matches our opening window of relevance perfectly is probably much more significant to us than it might be to another team on a different timeline (and I'm completely willing to accept that Buffalo is ahead of the Ducks in contention possibility).

Though the price is probably fair for Comrie, I doubt the Jets will bring him back. They will likely go with a league minimum backup if Hellebuyck is back as they have done for years. If Hellebuyck is gone, then they'd want a goalie better than Comrie.