Quoting: Leafsfan98
This post has many problems:
1. Dubois isn't signing an offer sheet at 4.2 million dollars even for 1 year... This is his window to make the most money possible and he would be advised to take it (not discussing if he earned it, just if he should take that boatload of cash).
2. MTL should be done offer sheeting players after they dropped the ball with Aho. If MTL offer sheets Dubois, this proves that they are a poverty franchise with no redemption
3. Why would WPJ offersheet someone in response? if Dubois leaves, they should go into full rebuild mode and trade for assets to make a run in the future
4. Neither franchise's fans will get what they want... MTL only wants to give up Anderson and 1 1st, WPJ want the farm system... I would use a combination of the Timo Meier trade and Bo Horvat trade as comparables so 2 1st, A prospect (Beck or something) and a young and good roster player (Not Josh Anderson)
This post has many problems:
1. I specifically said the following:
"However, this would require PLD to take a pay cut of at least 1.8 million for one year.
So, the risk that PLD would sign an offersheet in this case is rather low."
2. There are some that think Montreal is not done with offer-sheets.
Some Habs ACGMs on Capfriendly recently have been about offersheeting PLD.
And Marc D'Amico wrote a whole article about it.
https://montrealhockeynow.com/2023/03/28/montreal-canadiens-possible-canadiens-negotiation-tactic-to-pry-pierre-luc-dubois-from-jets/
3. Because if Winnipeg does not respond, then it sets a bad precedent.
Any team could then poach their best players with an offersheet and be left unpunished.
It's why Carolina offersheeted Kotkaniemi.
4. Why would Montreal trade multiple assets for Dubois when they can sign him for free next year?
Also, players who had their offer-sheet matched can't be traded for 1 full year.