So you're a Tampa fan

Marner in for Skinner.

(i assume you are forcing 1 player per team)

You know the all-star teams are only 11 players per team right?! 8 players are selected per team and 3 fan votes (1 G and 2 skaters)

Matthews over Thompson (scheifele would agree after last night)
Rielly over Forsling
For this season: Sammy over Vasy (Sammy has more wins, a .920 save percentage and a 2.12 GAA compared to Vasy's fewer wins, a .917 save percentage and a 2.50 GAA)
Marner/Tavares in for Skinner

Nope. If you are upset about Marner see below.


Yes, 1 per team.

I didn't think Marner played LW and I was trying to keep everyone in position, but it look like he's played ~15 mins of it this season with Matthews and Nylander so I'll accept it.


Yes. I just wanted to make 23 man rosters for each division.


I think the Thompson or Matthews could go either way. I think Thompson has had the better year so far, but you could definitely argue that Matthews is still the better player right now. However, between the stats and my secret Buffalo agenda, it is what it is.

I like Forsling. I tend to favour players with more games and on worse teams so don't take it personally.

Again tend to favour more games played. Vasy faces 4 more shots per game with only a -0.03 SV% difference. He also has more wins with 20 to Sams 14 but I'll assume you meant win %. Better than Bob though so he'll make the snub list

Yes I agree. Marner > Skinner

I prefer Matthews bc he has developed a 2 way game while keeping his scoring touch. According to Zegras, Matthews is the best at puck recoveries in his defensive zone. I am also 100% biased towards Matthews and think he is still one of (if not the) best centres in the NHL.

I prefer Rielly over Forsling but that's just me

Personally, Sammy has better stats in my opinion

Thanks for the change