Quoting: T0R
I know that but i still have nucks fans up my butt about paying too little. Litterally had someone tell me a 1st,2nd,Minten,Kerfoot,Topi for Schenn & Horvat 50%. Nucks fans man, they think a rental holds amazing value when in reality they don’t, Same thing they thought with Miller last season “He Is wOrTh So MuCh MoRe”. They over valued him & got 0 assets when they should’ve cashed in
My valuation of the trade you have there is essentially a 1st, three 3rds, two 2nds for Schenn and Horvat @ 50% (as a rental). Horvat as a rental (if you can fit him in at full pay) should be somewhere in the Roster player (just to plug a hole ei Kerfoot here), Upper tier prospect, 1st round pick (maaaaybe a little bit more) then with retention add a 3rd.
Kerfoot, Roni, '24 1st, '23 3rd for Horvat @ 50% is going to be one of the better offers they'll receive imo. That leaves Topi + '25 3rd for Schenn which is a little premium for my taste. This offer is nothing to scoff at but if it were to happen and not pan out for TOR then it hurts even more.
You're not too far off the more I look at it but an extension for Horvat @ a reasonable AAV would make this a no brainer for TOR imo. As a rental this trade favours VAN.