Why do we need Robertson when we have Sean Farrell?

As for the need to trade for Karlsson, it's debatable. I'm against.

The leafs trade is horrible for mtl and i wouldnt want Karlsson for that package, yes he would be an upgrade in the short term but there no guarantee he is still producing like this in 2-3 years when habs will actually be looking to compete. Doesnt make any sense to me. Robertson is a small winger, we have plenty of those coming up with Farrell and Roy on the cusp i wouldnt move Harris straight up for him let alone that whole package.

I doubt SJS accepts that Karlsson trade but Karlsson is about the last thing the Habs need.

That's 3 MTL passes as well as a SJ pass here champ. Are you even a Habs fan? wtf...

Rangers aren't paying 4.5 mil for a 4C. Let alone adding a straight cap dump in Dadononv.

With this lineup, the Habs are a goalie away from a deep cup run (on the backs of kids!). That's why.

Edmunson is a liability for Montreal, the Leafs can still use him (barely) for his playoff poise.

Harris has immense value but Montreal is too stacked on the LHD. Robertson is a stud. People talk about Knies being Toronto's stud, I love Robertson.

With Beck and Mesar in the system we need to move Dvorak while he still has value. Between him or re-signing Monahan cheap next year, I would choose Monahan.

Hoffman does not fit on this team. Mailloux has too much history but will be the next potential Erik Karlsson (iff the NHL ever lets him play, which is more likely if gets away from Hockey Canada). Baron is a soft underachiever, he needs somewehre else to grow, there is no room for his style of play in Montreal, he also deserves better than to die in Laval.

As for Erik Karlsson, he left Ottawa becasue of Hoffman and his girfriend. His health is back on track now. If you know EK you know he trains like a beast and will be effective for 4 more years.

@Rangers fan, I'm pretty sure Dvorak is the definition of a C between #2 and #3. Saying #4 sounds like a you problem. He is a PK and faceoff specialist. His contract is a steal...just not when you are overloaded with centres. Dadonov is a UFA so he is basically free as you approach the deadline. Kravtsov deserves a try at a fresh start, he brings little to the NYRs now.

1st round pick for Robertson or no deal

SJ is not taking Mallioux. that history not playing in this market

No need, just for fun! I think he might win the Norris...