Quoting: BadaBing
The UFA would be signed for the trade to happen and it gives the PENS a solid Center for the next 6 years min. Mailloux is projected to get 69 pts in 63 games and will be a Top pairing D, A Solid LHD who is now healthy and a solid prospect in Mysak. Not a bad haul for a player that would be 36yrs old playing for the HABS
Monahan is a middle-6 C at best, and I don't know if I'd sign a guy with his injury to a 6 year deal.
Mailloux is a 19 year old in the OHL, I would hope he would be putting up big numbers (also it's 12 points in 11 games, which now gives him 21 points in 27 OHL games going back to 2019)
Edmundson has missed significant time with back injuries over the past 2 seasons and will be 30 next year - and will be going to a team that has Marcus Pettersson, Jan Rutta, PO Joseph, & Ty Smith as guys who can play LD next season. Not exactly a position with a strong need for Edmundson.
Mysak has 3 goals and 0 assists in 36 career AHL games. Gonna need to see *something* at that level before I call him a prospect.
And trying to downplay it by saying he's a "a player that would be 36yrs old playing for the HABS" like he's not Sidney friggin' Crosby, still putting out a PPG+ pace at 35 years old, is an all time undersell. He's one of the greatest players in NHL history and is still performing as a no-doubt 1C, and you've offered a 1st rounder, two mediocre roster players, and two mediocre prospects.
I recognize this is all purely hypothetical because he's not getting traded, but if you wanted to do this deal I'd say you're giving up two of your 1sts (probably one of the 2023s & a 2024), Kirby Dach, and then another prospect in the B-tier (Justin Barron/Owen Beck-level players) to get a player like Crosby.