Aman has been better than Joshua imo

Disagree. Aman has had lots of lapses with not being sure what to do with the puck and coughing it up. Send him down let him stew a bit and then he gets first injury call up.

Joshua adds grit and body but is also scoring and plays hard every shift. He also had good chemistry with Lazar who will come back soon enough.

Who steps out when Lazar comes back?

And Stillman is a bad trade for the Canucks and is hurting Rathbone. Totally agree let Rathbone play!!

Joshua. Easy. Lazar was the best member of the opening night 4th line.

I actually agree with @cooliny that Aman is better than Joshua - Aman is more consistent. However I think your point about the grit is why he would appear ahead on the depth chart.

Joshua and Aman have two very unique skillsets. Joshua may be the more tenacious and aggressive forechecker, but Aman is way more defensively responsible and better in the faceoff dot, which I think outweighs what Joshua brings to the table when you consider that Lazar has been struggling with faceoffs as well.

That's a really good point. O would you choose Lazar over Joshua? Or maybe take out podkolzin, he isn't producing maybe needs a seat for a few games.