Not trying to be mean but a 3rd/4th liner, a top prospect, TWO 1sts, and a 2nd all for a 2nd/3rd liner and a 4th? If i was the Isles GM and got offered that i would hang up the phone without answering.
If you ask me then at that point if i'm the Islanders i at least say no but then without an answer after that i hang up the phone. So i would just say "no" and hang up the phone. Just my opinion though.