Overpayment from the Flames

Actually it’s probably fair

Underpayment From The Flames

Tarasenko's rental value isn't that much less than Pastrnak's so I see this as a fairly surprising take from a Bruins fan.



Personally I think the trade is pretty fair if it fits teams needs. But I see it as more of a deadline thing and maybe without retention

Yea Our gm doesn’t retain at all so that won’t happen
I also would rather have Pelletier than Zary
And Kylington would be very unneeded here too

Counter offer: Make it Coronato, Lucic and your 23 1st for Tarasenko, and you have a deal today.

You would prefer the more NHL ready prospect? Thats not surprising.

Zary will very likely have a significantly better year actually playing top 6 and on special teams in the AHL this season. He is also a center prospect unlike Pelletier.

Is the Leddy deal the only reason you don't like the addition of Kylington?



Calgary would never do that for a rental

A rental and a cap dump. But yeah, I know. I'm just negotiating here.

I dont see STL selling but I also dont see the above value as far off at all

Yea I mean he have leddy Krug Scandella mikkola and Scotty P so our left side is good
And on RHD we are super good

Also about the Coranto part is be fine with him too one of those 3

The Blues aren't rebuilding and have 6 NHL level LDs. You can talk about value, but if it isn't the right value, it ain't gonna fly. Like you said, offloading Tarasenko has to be worth it. The package above ain't the right value.

I dont think you are understanding. IF they are trying to move out Krug and or Scandella (and Tarasenko) which is widely reported despite a "non-rebuilding team", then they are going to need more cost effective D men to replace them, (this is all IF) hence I think actually Kylington would be a non starter from there end to leave in. Zary is only a few years off, and if you really don't want to rebuild, then that's fine, we will just keep our 1st, and gladly take yours too since you wont need it. You say your not looking to rebuild on one reply, and the other you say you don't want the only established NHL player in there. Nobody is giving a core piece for a UFA forward at 7.5M in todays cap space. I understand you would like more, but just not gonna get it.

Just curious, who's your 6th? Rosen? I wouldn't call him much of an NHL defenseman.

Yes, Rosen. And he's played solidly for the Blues. But if you wish to consider it 5 instead of 6, the point remains. I like Kylington, but they aren't going to spend value in a Tarasenko trade on another LD.

I was simply asking about who the 6th was in your opinion, not about the trade

Gotcha. Yep, Rosen is the sixth.