That's a lot for one year of JT Miller, considering I don't think Pittsburgh will have the space to resign him next year.
Jason Zucker's had a rough time in Pittsburgh, but I think Hextall is willing to ride out the last year of his deal and let him walk. If Pacioretty gets traded for less than nothing, the trade to dump Zucker isn't worth it.
Pickering and Poulin are the only two guys the Penguins have drafted in the 1st round in years. They aren't off the table, but I'd want more than one year of whoever I got for them.
Maniscalco is whatever. I don't think Vancouver would be that interested. His inclusion feels like quantity over quality.
With how stacked 2023 is reported to be, I'm hesitant to give up our 1st. Considering our last two 1sts we traded were for Kapanen and Zucker, excuse me for being hesitant. Pittsburgh's prospect puddle is still pretty shallow. It's the oldest team in the league. Maybe we should be holding onto these.
Travis Dermott doesn't help at all. We already 9 NHL caliber defensemen, so his inclusion does more harm than good for the Pens, imo.

And honestly? I think it's too late for a Miller trade. Vancouver had a nightmare season last year, and unless the same happens, they should be competing for a playoff spot. Pettersson and Hughes are entering their primes. The additions of Mikheyev and Kuzmenko improve their forward core, and Podkolzin and Hoglander are expected to take a step forward. JT Miller would still be a veteran presence, an elite player, and a leader on this team that has a good shot. Now isn't the time to trade him.

Very good honest post. enjoyable and informative read.Well said