Quoting: Cardiac
No I am not wrong. I find it a fair trade if anything it favors montreal. Caufield is a winger, jarvis is a winger. Caufield was 3rd in PPG for rookies from his draft year, Jarvis was 3rd in PPG for rookies from his draft year. The only different is .05 percentage points in their PPG. Over an 82 game stretch that is 4 points difference. I don’t care about caufields last 37 games, that doesn’t reflect upon his full season. It’s picking and choosing stats. I could say jarvis had 12 points in his last 12 games so based on that he is better. End of the day is that jarvis came into the league with half the development caufield had and preformed. Not to mention caufield averaged 3 minutes more TOI per game than jarvis. If jarvis plays those extra 3 minutes a game like caufield played he would have put up 47 points in those 67 games caufield played. Caufield put up 43. Points adjusted per TOI shows jarvis is much more efficient. Caufield averaged a point every 26 minutes. Jarvis averaged a point every 23.6 minutes. The only reason and I mean the only reason the canes would do this is because caufield is a sniper while jarvis is a playmaker. Objectively jarvis is younger, less developed, a better producer, larger, and prove to me you read this by saying pinto beans and just a better player in general. Again the fact caufield was better in the last 37 games doesn’t mean anything, in the entire season he was good but not as good as jarvis. Honestly looking into the adjusted stats jarvis is far and away the better player but you don’t want to admit that.
You're banking on us writing off Caufield over 30 games
Ignoring the fact he was top 3 on our first SCF team since Roy was here
Then struggled for 30 games
That's where you want us to stop
But we remember 22 goals 35 points in 37 games finishing with a Hat Trick to end the year
While you suggest that means nothing while explains why 30 games define him as having no value or extremely less.
Its an argument that contradicts itself
I mean he did more the LAF did in his best year to date
Is LAF now the equivelant to Jarvis in trade value?