Pelletier has more value than Anderson. Adding a top 4 defenseman is straight trolling

Im shocked you're an Oilers fan given that awful trade

Flames fans are convinced Pelletier is the second coming. They think his upside is higher than Dylan Holloway's. Would you trade Holloway & Kulak for Anderson?

Pelletier is hot-housing in Flames system & came off a breakout rookie season in A. Potential is hi & cap hit is low, why would they trade him out for some else's cap relief? I would argue Flames package for Toffoli (late 1st in weak draft; fringe NHLer @ end of career w/ expiring contract & B prospect) is significantly less then Kylington (young, established top 4) & Pelletier (recent 1st round pick w/ solid trajectory). And w/ fit & contract situation considered, Toffoli is more valuable to Calgary then Anderson (especially w/ potential Lucic deal for last 2-3 years of Anderson). So Mtl would 1000x do trade but hard NO from Calgary every day of the week.

simple answer. no. josh andersons garbage

I know that you are a dickie, but how on earth a player in the greatest league of the world can be garbage? Do you understand your nonsens?

Everyone's saying that Josh is garbage and that his contract is horrible, but honestly he's a pretty good leader in the locker room and create space for smaller guys.
He's not gonna score 25+ goals that's for sure, but he's useful in his own way. People are underestimates the impact Josh can have.
Not saying that dealing him for Pelletier is fair, but he's worth more than people think.