Ottawa part of the deal seems fair but the Leafs are giving up way too much. Two 1sts and their two top prospects.

Leafs are not giving up Knies and Topi which are the team's best prospects......Knies will be playing with the Leafs in next year's playoffs after his college season is over and is the real deal.

Murray at half retained isnt a positive value asset. You aren't adding anything extra on top of Miller in this case and the Leafs obviously decline that for 1 season of Miller as it's more than the rumored 4 piece deal they wanted at the trade deadline but for less term.

Sub the 2024 1st for a lesser pick then.

No....Scrap Topi and Knies and rework the deal.

It probably fair for the 2023 1st, Niemala/Liljegren, and Knies

If I’m the Canucks I take the 1st-Liljegren-Knies. I left Lily out of this deal as I thought TOR would rather keep him.

So you want JT Miller 50% retained without giving up a single round respect? How about we give him to you for free. Liligren/Niemala, a first and Knies for Miller 50%

Edited the TOR trade

Adding Kerfoot adds way more money going to VAN. The way you have it TOR in getting $5.7Min cap. Van is getting $11.6M. That deals needs to lose Kerfoot or add a pick/prospect for the additional $$$$

This looks really good, I think that we wouldnt have to send mikey out and Ideally we wouldnt, but I really like this, very well done

Toronto declines