NOT IF THAT'S THEIR OFFER

Canucks reject but don't spit the Niagara Falls in your face. The least they can do is spare you that after yet another failure in the first round

Knies, Liljegren, 1st as a starter

and a LOT of faith in dubnyk, a man who was cut from the olympic team. You would be better off looking in russia for a goalie.

Why the would the leafs want Dubnyk? Get rid of boosh and dubnyk contract. Sign husso, that’s probably ur best bet right there to make it far

Never, leaf’s aren’t trading there top prospect and there young defencemen that could be potentially be good. And a first. Nope

You’re not getting Miller with that poor offer. Relying on Dubnyk as your starter also guarantees that you don’t even make it to the first round

Good, that means Miller won’t be going to Toronto. Do you leafs fans understand that acquiring a premium asset is going to cost a team premium assets? You don’t throw scraps around and get good playets

Pretty fair offer, Nucks fans complaining have screws loose. Thats essential 3 1sts in value (late 1sts but still 1st

He hit 99 points this year, played PP, PK, and even fought Gudas, what more do you want from a player?

Disagree, value cumulative might be close, but we are looking for quality pieces, not quantity pieces. Knies, Liljegren, 1st.

Thats an overpay for a rental. They also will definitely not be trading Liljgren. Refer to the Hall to Arizona trade. miller should get a bit more than that

Depends on how they view him, he will probably come with an extension in place, if toronto doesnt want to extend him, we can find another suitor.

Arizona isnt that generous

What do you think is a fair offer for Miller who is esentially a 1 year rental and can walk from the acquiring team in 1 year?

No he won't. Players dont get traded with extensions in place. I also edit my last message

dubnyk as your starter…good luck

99 point players dont get traded usually either. probably be along the lines of the seth jones trade

Massive overpayment........Knies is untouchable as Leafs top prospect and Liljegren may also be untouchable as well as coming off a great season as a right hand defenceman.

What are you talking about in scraps?.........Robertson was a 1rst round pick, a 1rst round pick, Hirvonen solid prospect and Kerfoot who had decent year are not scraps for 1 year rental of Miller.

Myers and Dickinson were also a 1st round pick. How about 2 1sts for 1? Myers and Dickinson for Matthews sounds fair

How do you even compare Matthews to Miller.......Matthews won 3 major hockey awards this year including 2 MVP's as voted by the writers and players.

I have thought all along that Miller is worth a young player, a prospect and a first round pick.

If Canucks can pull off this trade..........they effectively gain 3 young players plus their own first round draft pick.......which translates into 4 young players to join team and the young core of Hughes and Petterson.

Past first round pick does not equal first round pick or good assets. Wanna know some first round picks by Vancouver? Tanner Pearson, Jason Dickinson, Luke Schenn. We don’t know if Robertson will pan out. He isn’t even an A prospect. Kerfoot is a rental that we don’t need

You missed one very key bit of information. The Canucks want a GOOD young player, a GOOD TOP prospect.