Quoting: DucharmetheDOMinator
They're a good team
Paladin = superstar + Zibenajad = fringe 1C + Vatrano = played well, 2nd line caliber since coming
Kreider = played well. 50 + goals. Yes he overachiever, but he can get 40 next year + Strome = great 2C + Copp = played amazing since coming , he maybe unlocked something. Was always underrated and good
Lafreniere = played well these playoffs, can only get better + Chytil = was very clutch, maybe unlocked something that's been hidden for a while + kaako = I think he'll be traded for someone like Dach, who has potential
Lindgren = Your classic 2nd pair dman + Fox = superstar dman
Miller = probably unlocked something too, he's been improving alot this year + Trouba = he plays well, a very good 2nd pair dman
Shesterkin = top 3 goalie in league, he won't regress
It's a good team, in my head, I had this team going to the finals, no joke.
We probably see next year:
Paladin + Zib - Chytil
Kreider - Copp - Lafrenière
Goodrow - Dach - ???
Lindgren - Fox
Miller - Trouba
Shesterkin
This team is very much ahead of the Devils
And still has a chance to compete.
I'm telling ya, it wasn't a fluke
I think you're underrating Zibby, imo he's established himself as a definitive 1C. Over a point per game the last 4 years (cumulative) and he doesn't play with Panarin at even strength. Scheifele and Tavares have put up similar point per game numbers throughout their career and always been considered 1Cs, and Zibby is miles better everywhere else on the ice than Shuffles, plus he PKs which even Tavares doesn't do.
On the other hand you're overrating Strome, he's a low end 2C at best, he was literally a throwaway journeyman until Panarin, and while having chemistry with a superstar is valuable and can make a career (see: Kunitz, Dupuis, Okposo, etc.), he's not that good without him. I also think he's in line for a payday (arguable whether it's deserved or not, but it's coming, and if it's somewhere else he probably isn't living up to it), so he might not be there next year.
Which leads me to the next thing you overrate: their ability to keep this team together. In my eyes they can keep Copp OR Strome, not both, because both will want raises and top 6 minutes, so they pick one to be their 2C and let the other walk. Especially if they wanna hang onto Vatrano. If they buyout Nemeth, they get ~15.7mil to sign 10-11 guys. If they commit 5.5mil to a 2C (Strome or Copp), 2mil each to a decent backup and Vatrano (discount btw, so maybe not even realistic), ~1.5mil each to Blais (would suck PR-wise for him to walk and they probably don't want that anyway) and Kakko (1 year prove it deal, don't think he gets dealt, they probably run the kid line as line 3 next year), then league min to a 3LD, 3RD, 4C, and spare, they can fit a 21 man roster. But that means they lose one of Copp/Strome, lose Motte, lose Georgiev for a cheaper backup, and might even have to trade Reaves (one of Blais or Goodrow would be at 2RW in this hypothetical).
Kreider-Zibanejad-Vatrano
Panarin-Copp-Blais
Lafreniere-Chytil-Kakko
Goodrow-Rooney-Reaves
Good team, still needs a top 6 scoring forward though. And the 3rd pair will likely be a weakness unless 2 of Jones/Schneider/Lundkvist step up big.
I also don't think 40 is realistic for Kreider, he might get there but he's been a fairly consistent 30 goal pace guy his entire career (despite never actually hitting it until this year) so that's probably closer to the right ballpark.