Couldn't you add Grityuk to this as well?
His deal with Omsk is up in 2023.

Hill for a 3rd Reimer cost a 2nd and a 4th

Says who lol

Maybe. Who knows with the situation in Russia.

they were asking a 1st and a prospect at the deadline so i imagine it hasn’t fallen much, sharks want to keep Kahkonen and Reimer and deal Hill, to change their mind you’d have to offer up something close to our deadline ask and a 2nd plus a 4 th seems fair for a goalie many rank in the top 15 this year and only makes 2.25 mil

He’s 35 and a pending UFA. You’re not getting a top 40 pick for him cmon.

You really think they draft Cooley considering they have Hischier Hughes and Mercer already? Don't think its Slafkovsky or nemec?

fair, then delete him and offer up a 3rd for hill or go after a FA, cause a 3rd does not get you reimer, and Fleury is 37 has worse stats than Reimer was only signed to the end of the year for 7 mil and got a 2nd that can become a 1st. you’d get Reimer all year for only 2,25. i don’t think i’m being unreasonable.

No. But I think passing on Cooley would be a massive mistake. Drafting for position in the NHL is stupid.

Counterpoint: this is my ACGM and I’m not going to change it because you think it might cost more? Especially when I think your valuation of a 35 year old pending UFA to be insane. Pick 69 is great value for him:

Devils pick at 5th overall, Cooley easily goes top 4 doubt he falls to 5th overall.

Lol I remember when Devils fans were saying that there wasn’t much difference between Quinn Hughes and Ty Smith

Do you have this comment saved on the clipboard and ready to go?

Regardless, fans who thought that were insane. Quinn is incredible. But if you’re gonna get hung up on the insane homer takes people have on this site, you might have a bad time

devs have a better shot at savoie than cooley

so this is pure fantasy then? why didn’t you trade NYR a 2nd for sheskertin? i’m telling you the sharks value Reimer a lot and Hill is the one being dealt not reimer unless they get a compelling offer. Reimer was the 2nd best player on our team and the sole reason we were not in the basement the whole year. given a better team and some goal support he would have been a top 10 goalie this year. at 2.25 mil getting that kind of player who is also an outstanding locker room guy won’t come for just a 3rd

Sure he will. Because he’s 35 and a pending UFA. Getting unreasonably angry someone values your favorite player differently isn’t super healthy my man

Sharks decline

not angry but again this never happens Reimer is far more valuable than a 3rd to the sharks. why would they ask for a 1sr plus at the deadline then turn around and accept a 3rd? i’m just saying… and refusing to listen to other people and accept you might be wrong is very unhealthy.

supply and demand says we will, lots of teams in meet of a top 20 goalie (which he is) and not enough cap space to pay what they are worth equals a big demand for a top 20 guy making 2.25 mil. which means if your not ok offering a. 2nd plus another pick there is another team out there who will. simple as that. and if your right and no one pays that price sharks keep their most dependable option in net

He is 33rd in GSAx/60 among goalies with 10 starts lol

So you can argue he’s literally not even a starter.

He’s 15th in total WAR thought according to EH but 20th in WAR/60 for goalies with > 500 minutes

We dont have to gift him to NJ because you have no NHL goalies

My g I’m very willing to learn. You were the one who said “delete the trade and replace it” and are making definitive assertions as if you’re the GM lol

Correct. Your GM can choose to do whatever he wants.

I’d be pretty surprised if he goes for a top 50 pick, though. Pick 69 seems totally fair, to me, based on his stats (the ones beyond sv% and GAA), age, and expiry status.

i said if your not wiling to adjust you might as well delete it, wow you can stand pat and tell
me i’m dead wrong then turn around and act like a victim. dude i’m done your not pleasant to discuss things with and your unreasonable.

Have a normal one pal