Quoting: LetsGoPens69
In what world is Manson > than Chiarot?? U mean 4 years ago?? Ya, 4 years ago Manson had value. Now he doesn’t. He’s had 3 sub-par years.
Let alone Chiarot’s Defensive analytics and underlying numbers are superior—any year.
And now I’m going to quote a guy with whom I have frequent vigorous discussions:
"Funny, I was thinking the opposite. Manson is a better defender than Chiarot. Colorado has a very strong analytics department so they would have known that, of course.
5v5 On-ice Rels, this season
Chariot vs Manson
-2.66 CF% Rel +4.25
-3.65 GF% Rel +6.03
-5.15 xGF% Rel +0.72
-2.14 SCF% Rel +2.90
-6.54 HDCF% Rel +5.00
39.74 Off. Zone Start % 39.42
Manson’s shot-, goal-, scoring chance- and expected goal-suppression is far superior as he actually does good work in these areas, while Chiarot allows more of each than his teammates do. Chiarot has no advantage anywhere, not even in the scoring department:
0.31 Goals/60 0.32
0.68 Total Points/60 0.64
0.56 Primary Points/60 0.56
4.5 Shots/60 4.53
0.16 ixG/60 0.26
2.78 iSCF/60 3.26
0.43 iHDCF/60 1.11
Similar style, similar usage, but only one of these guys is effective at his job."
You can find further discussion on this point in https://www.capfriendly.com/forums/thread/566100
You might find it enlightening.