You realize Brodie plays almost strictly RD right? Like he's significantly worse on the left. Anyways Toronto doesn't do that

Toronto passes. Giving up their most reliable dman who plays the right side for two LD? No deal

This a joke?

Yikes, yeah not even close for the leafs, this makes em worse now, especially defensively

??

Marner and Robertson for krieder laf and schnieder, still honestly wouldn’t do it but I think it’s a lot closer and the leafs would have to consider it

Kreider > Marner

This season he is but Marner has more value

Neither team does this but if you want to talk value then NYR is giving up more

Krieder is nice, and Kakko and Miller have potential, but overall nothing there is worth Marner, let alone Brodie and Robertson. If they trade Marner it's either because they are rebuilding, they are trading him for someone better, or they get a top pairing right d and a top line forward. This package is not any of those things.