Montreal declines. We could get more and not have to employ Koskinen.

Gives a 1st for Chiarot and not Hertl

I dont think I would even go 1 for 1 Puljujarvi for Hertl.

You underpaid, significantly, for the player of real value (Hertl) and overpaid on almost everyone else.

Debrusk in particular. Yammer 1 for 1 is fair. 2nd or Foeggle and low end prospect or pick is fair.

If the sharks do that trade I would want an extension already for Puljujarvi and maybe a 1st instead for taking on Barrie and his contract

Don't think Hertl wants to play with Evander Kane again lol, think he's done with that guy

Broberg for georgiev wow. Georgiev is worth a first round pick or something like 2 seconds plus Samorukov.

What? Yikes take there

Hertl is a rental probably due for a pay raise as well.

Edmonton doesnt need 1st or second line center they need wingers who forecheck hard and can score. hertl is going to free agency and proably gets 7 Million Puljujarvi is under team control.

Wow this is all really bad for Edmonton and does nothing to save their season.

Save the season by loosing 5 trades in a row. Ok let’s get past this mindset charelli has been gone for awhile now.

And your point?

2nd and Puju is FMV. SK just a spare part. Barrie’s only value is on the PP other than that he’s a detriment. Having term makes adding him even worse. Brings value down.

If SJ trades Hertl it will be for a 1st and decent prospect.

I wouldn't trade yamamoto and foegele for debrusk. I'd pick one or the other and add something. Yamamoto is a right winger so he is a little more valuable and is better defensively if they end up playing him 3rd line.

I would do foegele + 2 second round picks for debrusk.

I think all moves aside from the SJ one are very bad for the Oilers. SJ will likely decline that one, although in the long-term that's also pretty bad for EDM too.

Trading a first for a rental is off limits in edmonton. Puljujarvi is no longer a prospect he is an established player. He is on pace for a 50 or 60 point season.

I did not say EDM shouid trade for Hertl. They are actually one of the last teams that should.

Which is why Puju and 2nd is FMV as opposed to the 1st/prospect. The rest of it drags value down and Sharks have no interest in it.

Then you dont get good players. First and prospect or nothing at all

Holloway and 1st. Nothing else works.

Overpayment on JD. Of course, I'd accept that in an instant