Go Habs Go
Rejoint: mars 2017
Messages: 10,667
Mentions "j'aime": 4,091
Toffoli is worth more and probably comes without retention. Good prospect, 1st or 2nd depending on interest (and Pittsburgh wouldn't be the only ones in on him), and an unwanted contract coming back is an option. That's assuming he is even made available.
Chiarot's value as a 1st is because he's the most prototypical "playoff" defenseman that is readily available and his cap hit is fairly low at only 50% retention.
Kulak is a 4th or 5th, maybe with conditions. Retention might add to that, but I think that comes in the form of a low grade prospect or additional pick.
Allen returns at least a 2nd or you don't trade him. Market for goaltenders is better in the off season.