For the reason you want Reinhart is the same reason Buffalo does. If Schenn and Haag don't excite you for the flyers why would it for Buffalo. Furthermore, if the situation was reversed do you make that deal? Would you, being the Flyers, trade reinhart for Schenn and Haag? Not in a million years.

You overvalued Schenn in this deal - he cannot play 5v5 at all. If you were to throw in Couturier, I think the deal would be more exciting.

The main piece coming back to Buffalo needs to be a young proven top-4 dman. Hagg doesn't help that

Yeah the only way I'd trade Reinhart is for Giroux with a little retained salary or Provorov straight up.

Hagg is NHL ready but our general manager, Ron Hextall, wants to properly develop our prospects. He is a potential top 4 dman is a damn good, but not elite.

There is no chance that you can trade anyone in the league for Provorov straight up. The only exception that comes to mind rn is McDavid, imo. Other than that, no chance does he get moved like that

the trade would be completely different so your point is moot. The Flyers need a center not winger so obviously I wouldn't trade an actually good center for a good winger. However, the point of this was a trade counter to something Zach and I were tlaking about so look at his trade offer before commenting..