5’10” is not the average height for an NHL defenseman.

And yes, having 3 defenseman like that would affect the team. They would want to play the same role, but there’s only so much to go around. And then who plays PK? Because neither Hughes nor Girard really do (Addison too green to know). And if you look at teams that have actually wind cups recently, they typically have a much taller/bigger group of defenseman.

I’m not saying these guys can’t succeed in the NHL at their size, but you should try to ice a more well-rounded blue line as opposed to 3 of the same player at different skill levels.

And no need to get offended or try to throw insults — just giving my opinion on a public post.

Hes off to a very slow start, has less years of team control, higher AAV, is a year older, and plays a less valuable position (winger vs D man). I just dont see how he can be more valuable

its not about whos more valuable its about how much value sackic views them, and it is reported that he is willing to trade girard, and avs need a new winger in the offseason.

For all reasons listed above I bet Sakic also values Girard higher. And the part about being willing to trade Girard is just not true.

https://theathletic.com/2960513/2021/11/16/lebrun-details-on-the-potential-penguins-sale-opting-out-of-the-olympics-blackhawks-gm-search-and-more/?s=09