McAvoy or Weegar?

Fox is 1 😤

Other than Carlson as an HM I agree with this

I agree with McAvoy as an Honorable mention but not Weager

I agree with McAvoy as an Honorable mention but not Weager

I agree with McAvoy as an Honorable mention but not Weager

I agree with McAvoy as an Honorable mention but not Weager

Hedman #1
Makar #2 (will become the #1 when Hedman start declining)
Fox #3

HM :
McAvoy
Heiskanen
Josi

IMO

Cale Makar is definitely in the top 5, but he's not #1. I expect a #1 or top 5 defenseman to be #1 in all areas of the ice for their team. Makar doesn't kill penalties. Fox and Hedman are #1 in 5 on 5, PP, and PK for their teams. They are better than Makar all around

Weegar is really good, but he's definitely not in the top 7-10 range

Weegar lmao

2021 numbers, oZS%:

69.7%
62.6%
51.6% (Fox...this one surprised me!)
59.4%
64.3%
57.3%
57.7%

I don't disagree with the list, but it's interesting how we value the guys who don't start in their own end very often, and don't show love to the dZS% guys...

Yup

Weegar is better than Carlson. Weegar isn't in the Top 10, but definitely better than Carlson

No they aren’t makar is also good at defense and kills penalties, makar is the best d man in the league

Replace Carlson with McAvoy and I agree

Please show me where his PK TOI insinuates that he regularly kills penalties...