2012 Redraft

Vasy may have the better Def in front of him, but there's no doubt he is the better goalie Hellebuyck is the second best in the league. And i dont really agree with some of your rankings.

Their pretty similar in a few ways

Aside from the top 2, which rankings do you disagree with?

Lindholm is better than Parayko, Gostisbhere and Trouba (only looking at Defensemen). And if we look at all players, then he'd also have to be before Korpisalo, Pearson, Galchenyuk, Anderson and Murray.

And Slavin > Rielly and Forsberg imo

Don’t forget Galchenyuk had a 30 goal season. Anderson and Murray were both beasts in net in 2016-2019 as well. Anderson is getting old so that’s understandable, but Murray is still young and can still bounce back with Ottawa

I mean they’re both franchise goalies and future HOFers

Murray wasn't a beast in 17/18, but 16/17 and 18/19 he was really good. Andersen was great in 13/14 and till 19/20 he was still pretty good. I think he'd be like 1 or 2 positions behind Lindholm. Yes, Galchenyuk had one 30 goal season, but he has been disappointing for 3 years now. But it's hard to redraft players with different positions, so I understand your point of view. But Lindholm should be higher than 20.